More videos have been released after a jury decided that the officer who shot and killed Mr. Philando Castile was not guilty of any charges. A jury of his peers decided he did nothing wrong. Mr. Castile is dead and this is just standard police training. What’s most important is that the officer made it out alive, right? Well, he’s been fired and will not be serving Mr. Castile’s community in the future. I have no idea how both these truths can coexist.
I sat and watched his death from the police officer’s dash camera and it is just as tragic. I can hear the anxiety in the police officer’s voice and I am disgusted. “If you are afraid, wait for back up to arrive. If you are afraid, why not interrogate your fear?” Because I hear nothing scary coming from the car.
I hear Mr. Castile’s voice and I feel helpless and weak. I know that he is going to die just like the other African Americans before him and we will blame them for it. It’s always their fault, right? Still, no gun in view much less drawn or aimed, Mr. Castile is shot to death.
In a matter of seconds, Mr. Castile is shot numerous times and I see another officer move away. The police officer who shot and killed Mr. Castile had not considered his partner who may have been in the line of fire or the other passengers, to include a four- year- old in the backseat, until afterwards. She climbs out of the car after witnessing the shooting. His partner grabs her. Isn’t that ironic?
It was “a split- second decision” that has changed her life forever. I watch another video and I hear her small voice warn her mother to watch her language. She doesn’t want her “to get shooted.” In a split- second, her perspective has changed and she now feels the need to police her mother’s behavior. Because it is more important that her mother maintain her composure after watching a fearful police officer kill the man she loves.
It was a split- second decision that involved the officer only thinking about his safety and no one else’s. He feared for his life and had to make a split- second decision to kill Mr. Castile? A decision based on fear of what could happen. But, wasn’t this why Mr. Castile greeted the officer with deference? Wasn’t that the reason why he told the officer that he had a registered firearm in the car? To calm his fears and to reassure him that he had no intentions to harm him. Because why would he tell the officer that he has a gun and then reach for it?
“Sir, I have a gun. Please wait while I reach for it to take your life with my family in the car. Put your heads down, girls.” In a split- second, this logic was not questioned. That Mr. Castile also wanted to go home. Because he knows the drill; records show that he had been stopped by police more than forty times. But, I am supposed to believe he now decides to kill a police officer?
I’m still trying to make sense of it but I can’t. There’s no real rationale for the continued employment of the shaky hands of Lady Justice. Because it shouldn’t have happened. Murdered out of fear when there has been year after year of nationally publicized police- involved shootings of African Americans? I would understand Mr. Castile’s fear but not the officer’s.
I know that this messes with our neat little boxes. Police officers swear to uphold the law so we don’t want to consider that they might break it. They are the good people and the African Americans are the bad people. There are cops and there are robbers. But, what happens to our boxes when the cops are doing the robbing?
See Jesus’ conversation with the Pharisees. He didn’t mince words butcalled these keepers of the law “white- washed graves” (Matthew 23.27). Jesus was quite comfortable with the inconsistences of our humanity and had no problem calling out their hypocrisies. Police officers are no different; they are under the same law. Call it like you really see it. Jesus would.
So, how then do we preach? Where will we stand behind our pulpits after the death of Mr. Castile? Will we pray for his family? Will we mention his name at all? Challenge ourselves to sit in the car with him and see justice from his eyes?
Or, will we simply pray for the police officers because they are trying to do the right thing? But, wasn’t that what Mr. Castile was attempting to do? The truth is that in our eyes, he wasn’t good enough. We don’t have to say it; our silence sums it up.
Yes, a police officer’s job is hard and dangerous. If someone is going to die, we would prefer it not be the good guy, right? Our conclusions are cut and dry, black and white. No grace and no wiggle room for Mr. Castile or his family in the car that day. It’s the law.
The Scriptures are not silent on matters of justice so why does the Church pretend to be? Instead, I would encourage my fellow preachers to speak authentically, openly, honestly and transparently about his death and what it means for you. And if it means nothing, ask yourself, “Why?” If you feel that he deserved it, ask yourself, “Why?” If you believe that you can do nothing to break this cycle, ask yourself, “Why?” And then write.
Perhaps, tomorrow’s sermon will be a lament. Maybe it will voice the cry of righteous anger or be an opportunity to ask necessary questions about how we can best serve our community in times of crisis. While you are searching for an appropriate Scripture for the subject matter, consider the position of the police officer and that of Mr. Castile. Then, ask yourself, “Where would Jesus be?”